Title: F
Director: Johannes Roberts
Released: 2010
Starring: David Schofield, Eliza Bennett, Ruth Gemmell, Juliet Aubrey, Emma Cleasby, Finlay Robertson, Roxanne McKee, Tom Mannion, Max Fowler, Jamie Kenna, Ian Cullen
Plot: After he is attacked by one of his students, Teacher Robert (Schofield) returns from three months of forced leave deeply affected by the incident only to soon find his worst fears realised while holding an after school detention when the school comes under attack by a group of shadow faced hoodies.
Review: After making his start directing micro budget horror films director Johannes Roberts finally got a bigger budget (150k) for this hoodie horror which taps into the headline fears of teachers struggling to deal with increasingly unruly students and a system designed to protect the students but not the teachers trying to teach them. This is discovered by David Schofield’s teacher Robert after he mockingly gives one of his students an F only to be headbutted by said student. Now faced with the school now wanting to be sued by the students parents and forced to take a break from teaching and unable to cope he descends into alcoholism and paranoia while his marriage collapses as he becomes ever more estranged from his daughter Kate (Bennett).
Upon returning to teaching it’s clear that he is a shell of his former self and this is really were the dramatic heft of Schofield really plays to the films advantage while his world weary cracked features only further sell his crumbling mindset as his fellow teachers talk about him behind his back and the students in his class run wild. But with his daughter (who handily is also one of his students) refusing to talk to him he figures why not put her into after school detention of course not knowing the school will come under attack from a gang of hoodies who start laying siege to the school and preying on the staff.
While the setup is certainly there for the film with the school providing plenty of potential victims and setups for grizzly fates for them to befall the film still manages to fall short despite a promising early start and an impressive early kill involving a security guard being set on fire inside a chained bin. From here though the film really starts to stumble as teachers are quickly introduced only to be even quicker disposed of to add to the body count. At the same time the kills are predominantly off screen with Roberts taking the moment right to the moment of pay off only to then cut away. Whether this was due to budget limitations or the belief that what you don’t show the audience is scarier than what you do, a technique that very few directors can actually pull off. Sure we do get to the see the aftermath of what happens to some of these characters and Dan Martin’s special effects make up is certainly impressive making it hardly surprising that he has gone onto work on films like Infinity Pool and Stopmotion while continuing to be a regular collaborator on Roberts projects.
The faceless hoodies are certainly a strong creation especially as they move around the school silently like ninjas and never speaking while combined with a pack like mentality as they close in on their victims which only adds to their mystique much like Roberts defiantly refusing to reveal their identity. Confusingly while he allows one of the group to be killed off he does leave the remainder to wander the hallways of the school as he opts for an ominous ending which doesn’t land and ends up leaving the film just feeling like it ends suddenly rather than on any kind of satisfying pay off nor redemption for Schofield’s character who ultimately is only more broken than he was when the night began and a character being sacrificed that didn’t deserve to be.
While watchable the film stumbles to live up to the high bar it sets for itself early on only to find itself on a spiral of increasingly disappointing pay offs. Roberts has more recently found better success with 47 Metres Down and its DTV sequel aswell rebooting The Strangers with he enjoyable The Strangers: Prey At Night but here hampered either by production limitations or plotting choices feels like more of a stumble.